Thursday, May 15, 2025
Beyond the Crime Scene
  • Home
  • News
  • True Crime Stories
  • Videos
  • Podcast
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • True Crime Stories
  • Videos
  • Podcast
No Result
View All Result
Beyond the Crime Scene
No Result
View All Result
Home News

Doctor kidnapped outside Brooklyn Mirage paid for $6K spending spree

by
August 17, 2023
in News
0
Graphic showing the different expenses for the night.
189
SHARES
1.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


It’s the “Hangover” — in real life.

A Connecticut doctor allegedly kidnapped outside the troubled Brooklyn Mirage music venue described how he was taken on a wild ride by his possibly gun-wielding captor — including on a more than $6,000 shopping spree, The Post has learned.

Michael Bautista, a 32-year-old ophthalmologist and cataract surgeon from Norwalk, claimed he was taken hostage by a Bronx man going by the name “Tony G’s,” who threatened to shoot him if he tried “anything funny,” police said.

The suspect, Anthony Benjamin, 42, allegedly forced Bautista to traipse with him through the Bronx on July 22 and 23, for an excursion that included pizza and smoothies, as well as hitting up a strip club and a Foot Locker, according to law enforcement sources.

Benjamin is accused of strong-arming the doctor into shelling out more than $1,800 at 4U House of Fitted Caps on White Plains Road; $1,100 at Foxy Fitness and Pole, a chain of pole-dance fitness schools; and nearly $1,700 at Foot Locker, sources said.

Benjamin — who allegedly said he was “packing” — also took Bautista to his barber, who chopped and styled the hijacker’s braided purple-and-black locks, according to an incident report from the Norwalk Police Department.

The doctor tried to play it cool until he could find a way out, cops said.


Graphic showing the different expenses for the night.
Michael Bautista described how he was taken on a wild ride by his possibly gun-wielding captor — including on a more than $6,000 shopping spree.
NY Post composite

Dr. Michael J. Bautista
Bautista was allegedly kidnapped outside the troubled Brooklyn Mirage music venue.
Norwalk hospital

But Benjamin allegedly got more aggressive as the day passed, telling Bautista that he’d “put people in body bags before” and that he wasn’t afraid to “let bullets fly,” according to the police report.

The bizarre odyssey — which didn’t end until Bautista told the security guards at his Connecticut hospital that he’d been kidnapped — started at the Brooklyn Mirage, the same venue from which two 27-year-old men disappeared on two different nights this summer before each turned up dead in a nearby creek.

Related articles

Upstate NY teen allegedly killed 14-year-old Samantha Humphrey after she said she was pregnant

Upstate NY teen allegedly killed 14-year-old Samantha Humphrey after she said she was pregnant

May 15, 2025
Cruise ship crime reaches 2-year high, casting ‘dark cloud’ for travelers: expert

Cruise ship crime reaches 2-year high, casting ‘dark cloud’ for travelers: expert

May 15, 2025

Residents have been asking elected officials to crack down on the shadowy characters who lurk in the industrial neighborhood, seemingly lying in wait for drunk or otherwise impaired patrons to stumble out into the night.

Bautista appears to have met one such character on July 21, when he got together with friends to go to a 10 p.m. show at the Mirage.


Aerial view of The Brooklyn Mirage, Brooklyn, New York. 05 August 2023.
Brooklyn Mirage is the same venue from which two 27-year-old men disappeared on two different nights this summer before each turned up dead in a nearby creek.
NY Post

When it ended, he hopped in a taxi and told the driver to take him back to his car, which was parked several blocks away, according to the report by Norwalk Police.

But another man — later identified as Benjamin — was allegedly already in the back seat when the doctor got in.

That’s when things apparently went south.

First, the driver told Bautista he could forget about his car, because he was taking the pair to an after-hours party in Manhattan whether he wanted to go or not, the report said.

The doctor and the driver got into an argument once they reached the nightspot: The driver wanted money, and the doctor refused.


Anthony Benjamin
The suspect, Anthony Benjamin, 42, allegedly forced Bautista to traipse with him through the Bronx on July 22 and 23, for an excursion that included pizza and smoothies, as well as hitting up a strip club and a Foot Locker.
Norwalk Police Dept

Benjamin — who according to sources stands about 6 feet tall and weighs 200 pounds — allegedly defused the situation after the driver tried to hit Bautista, the report said.

Benjamin convinced the doctor to hand out — he was a promoter for the event, after all. The doctor agreed “because he wanted to get off the street,” the report said.

But Bautista’s savior act turned weird once inside, as he claimed he was the doctor’s “protection” and said that he was “packing” — as he touched his waistband, the court document stated.

The doctor wanted to leave, but Benjamin “begged him to stay,” he told cops.

Keep up with today’s most important news

Stay up on the very latest with Evening Update.

The two went for a walk instead, then got in an Uber and headed back to Brooklyn. When they returned to the doctor’s car, Benjamin convinced him to drive him to the Bronx, the report said.

Benjamin allegedly started making comments about flying bullets and body bags — then he said he’d kill Bautista before laughing it off like it was a joke, the report stated.

Bautista must have missed the funny part, because he later told cops that Benjamin said, “If you do anything funny, I’ll kill you,” according to sources.

The pair stopped at several ATMs, where the doctor took out about $1,000 — and Benjamin handed some of the money out to friends in his Bronx neighborhood, the report stated.

Then they went on their shopping spree, which took them to several stores and a handful of Bronx restaurants — like Mario’s Pizzeria, Hollywood Delights, Freckles Juice and Family African Meat Market — to pick up more than $570 worth of food, according to sources.

They also stopped at a fitness studio called Foxy Fitness and Pole — where they spent $1,100, according to police sources.

“Bautista stated during the entire incident he was going along with what Benjamin wanted him to do,” Norwalk Police Officer Akeem Bryce wrote in the report.


Steve Daley
The alleged kidnapper recruited Steve Daley, 50, of Vernon, New York, to drive the pair to Norwalk because Benjamin didn’t know how to drive Bautista’s manual-transmission car.
Norwalk Police Dept

Eventually, the doctor told Benjamin that he was on-call that weekend, and that people would get suspicious if he didn’t show up to work.

So the alleged kidnapper recruited Steve Daley, 50, of Vernon, New York, to drive the pair to Norwalk because Benjamin didn’t know how to drive Bautista’s manual-transmission car, the report said.

When the trio arrived at Norwalk Hospital at about 4 a.m. Sunday, Benjamin told Bautista he should bring him inside and tell his colleagues that the purple-haired abductor was a visiting doctor.

Bautista told him he couldn’t — saying Benjamin needed credentials.

Once inside, he told the hospital security that Benjamin and Daley were waiting in a car outside. The guards locked down the hospital and called the cops.

Police later arrested the pair. It’s not known if a gun was recovered.

Connecticut police charged Benjamin with second-degree kidnapping with a firearm and possession of a controlled substance.

The court set his bond at $1 million, but he was later released after he promised to appear, according to court records.

Cops also charged Daley with conspiracy to commit second-degree kidnapping. His bond was set at $250,000, but he was released under the same promise.

Both are scheduled to appear in Connecticut Superior Court on Sept. 19. Neither returned requests for comment Wednesday.

Sources told The Post that it’s very likely the feds will take over the case because it involves interstate kidnapping.

Bautista did not respond to calls and texts seeking comment. An administrator at the ophthalmology practice he works for claimed she was speaking on his behalf – but would not comment beyond saying “the case is ongoing.”



Source link

Tags: brooklynconnecticutcrimekidnappingsMetro
Share76Tweet47
Previous Post

Woke California DA Pamela Price may face recall

Next Post

NYC woman, 64, injured after being shoved on subway platform

Related Posts

Upstate NY teen allegedly killed 14-year-old Samantha Humphrey after she said she was pregnant

Upstate NY teen allegedly killed 14-year-old Samantha Humphrey after she said she was pregnant

by
May 15, 2025
0

An Upstate New York teenager has been charged with murdering his 14-year-old girlfriend because she told him she was pregnant...

Cruise ship crime reaches 2-year high, casting ‘dark cloud’ for travelers: expert

Cruise ship crime reaches 2-year high, casting ‘dark cloud’ for travelers: expert

by
May 15, 2025
0

Crime rates aboard cruise ships leaving the US have reached a two-year high, and one expert says this creates a...

Why Miscarriages and Stillbirths Go Unreported Inside Ohio Jails

Why Miscarriages and Stillbirths Go Unreported Inside Ohio Jails

by
May 15, 2025
0

By Mark Puente, The Marshall Project, and Scott Noll, News 5 Cleveland Additional reporting contributed by Brittany Hailer Nearly five...

Serial Tesla road-rager Nathaniel Radimak beaten to a bloody pulp in prison after he's arrested for attacking mom, teen learning how to park

Serial Tesla road-rager Nathaniel Radimak beaten to a bloody pulp in prison after he’s arrested for attacking mom, teen learning how to park

by
May 15, 2025
0

Karma took the wheel. The serial Tesla road rage driver who landed back behind bars for allegedly assaulting a teen...

The victim was walking home around 9 a.m. Friday when the unidentified hooded gunman approached her from behind on a University Heights street and brazenly pointed the weapon without saying a word, authorities said. 

NYC woman, 32, lucky to be alive after stranger tries to shoot her from behind, missing her by ‘a centimeter’: cops

by
May 15, 2025
0

A 32-year-old Bronx woman is lucky to be alive after a stranger randomly fired a single round at the back...

Load More
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
The horrifying rape, torture murder of eight-year-old Nurin Jazlin Jazimin : True Crime Diva

The horrifying rape, torture murder of eight-year-old Nurin Jazlin Jazimin : True Crime Diva

May 29, 2023
Drunk driver who killed mother and son blamed the victims, phone calls with father reveal

Drunk driver who killed mother and son blamed the victims, phone calls with father reveal

September 22, 2024
Mackenzie Shirilla

Father of Mackenzie Shirilla’s boyfriend doesn’t support life sentence

August 20, 2023
Karen Styles: map of where a deer hunter found her body

The 1994 murder of Karen Styles

May 9, 2023
The Murder of Latanisha Carmichael – TRUE CRIME REPORT

The Murder of Latanisha Carmichael – TRUE CRIME REPORT

June 7, 2023
The Unsolved Murder of Karina Holmer – TRUE CRIME REPORT

The Unsolved Murder of Karina Holmer – TRUE CRIME REPORT

September 3, 2023
The tragic story of solo traveler Emma Kelty

The tragic story of solo traveler Emma Kelty

May 15, 2023
Karen Styles: map of where a deer hunter found her body

The 1994 murder of Karen Styles

0
Dwane Roy Dreher: photo of his 2nd wife, Lois Genzler Dreher at 16 years old

The 1955 disappearance of U.S. Navy veteran Dwane Roy Dreher

0
Alta Braun: professional photo taken when she was about 4 years old.

The 1917 unsolved murder of Alta Marie Braun

0
Vacation Nightmare: The gruesome murder of Janice Pietropola and Lynn Seethaler

Vacation Nightmare: The gruesome murder of Janice Pietropola and Lynn Seethaler

0
Kristi Nikle: photo of suspect Floyd Tapson

The 1996 disappearance of Kristi Nikle

0
Frank and Tessie Pozar: photo of their son, Frank Pozar, Jr.

Motel Mystery: What happened to Frank and Tessie Pozar?

0
Evil on The Road Part 4: Desmond Joseph Runstedler

Evil on The Road Part 4: Desmond Joseph Runstedler

0
Upstate NY teen allegedly killed 14-year-old Samantha Humphrey after she said she was pregnant

Upstate NY teen allegedly killed 14-year-old Samantha Humphrey after she said she was pregnant

May 15, 2025
Cruise ship crime reaches 2-year high, casting ‘dark cloud’ for travelers: expert

Cruise ship crime reaches 2-year high, casting ‘dark cloud’ for travelers: expert

May 15, 2025
Why Miscarriages and Stillbirths Go Unreported Inside Ohio Jails

Why Miscarriages and Stillbirths Go Unreported Inside Ohio Jails

May 15, 2025
Serial Tesla road-rager Nathaniel Radimak beaten to a bloody pulp in prison after he's arrested for attacking mom, teen learning how to park

Serial Tesla road-rager Nathaniel Radimak beaten to a bloody pulp in prison after he’s arrested for attacking mom, teen learning how to park

May 15, 2025
The victim was walking home around 9 a.m. Friday when the unidentified hooded gunman approached her from behind on a University Heights street and brazenly pointed the weapon without saying a word, authorities said. 

NYC woman, 32, lucky to be alive after stranger tries to shoot her from behind, missing her by ‘a centimeter’: cops

May 15, 2025
Maniac with 20 prior arrests busted in random attack on L.A. grandma, 70, in NYC subway station: sources

Maniac with 20 prior arrests busted in random attack on L.A. grandma, 70, in NYC subway station: sources

May 15, 2025
What's next for the Menendez brothers? Here's how soon Lyle and Erik could walk free

What’s next for the Menendez brothers? Here’s how soon Lyle and Erik could walk free

May 14, 2025
Beyond the Crime Scene with Bee Astronaut

Categories

  • Featured
  • News
  • Podcast
  • True Crime Stories
  • Videos

Legal Pages

  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA)
  • DMCA

© 2023 All right reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • True Crime Stories
  • Videos
  • Podcast

© 2023 All right reserved.