Thursday, May 8, 2025
Beyond the Crime Scene
  • Home
  • News
  • True Crime Stories
  • Videos
  • Podcast
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • True Crime Stories
  • Videos
  • Podcast
No Result
View All Result
Beyond the Crime Scene
No Result
View All Result
Home News

NY’s lefty leaders have not backed Gov. Hochul’s bid to fix state’s twisted evidence laws — despite surge in support

by
March 26, 2025
in News
0
NY's lefty leaders have not backed Gov. Hochul's bid to fix state's twisted evidence laws -- despite surge in support
189
SHARES
1.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter



The leaders of the state Legislature have yet to fully endorse Gov. Kathy Hochul’s bid to reshape New York’s twisted evidence laws — even as her plan sees a surge of bipartisan support.

Hochul’s proposal — which she argues would help stop criminal cases from being dismissed over “technicalities” — faces an uncertain fate with Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie (D-Bronx) and Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins (D-Westchester) in Albany.

Heastie believes that some of the changes would give prosecutors too much power. James Messerschmidt

Heastie said Tuesday that Assembly members broadly agree so-called discovery laws need to be tweaked, but are still haggling over details during the ongoing state budget negotiations.

He expressed concern that some of the Hochul-backed changes would give prosecutors too much power.

“I’m not pro-defendant, I’m not pro-prosecutor,” he said. “I’m pro-justice, wanting a fair exchange of discovery and let the wheels of justice turn. But I think the conversation is in a very good place.”

Stewart-Cousins has said amendments to the discovery laws should happen outside the budget talks. Hans Pennink

The state budget deadline is technically April 1, but lawmakers have blown past it in the past amid discussions on contentious topics such as bail reform.

Neither Heastie nor Stewart-Cousins included Hochul’s proposed discovery changes in their one-house budget proposals for this year.

And Stewart-Cousins has said amendments to the discovery laws should happen outside the budget talks, The New York Times reported.

Hochul, for her part, has thrown her support behind a crusade by prosecutors across the state to roll back aspects of discovery laws that were changed in 2019’s wave of criminal-justice reforms signed by then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo and enacted the following year.

Hochul has thrown her support behind a crusade by prosecutors across the state to roll back aspects of discovery laws. Mike Groll/Office of Governor Kathy Hochul

Her proposal would narrow the scope of evidence that is required to be turned over to the defense. It would also set a timeline for defendants to challenge whether prosecutors are in full compliance and grant judges more leeway on how to sanction prosecutors who run afoul of the rules, short of dismissing a case in its entirety.

District attorneys across New York — including all five in the city — have argued the onerous requirements on turning over evidence have led to a rash of case dismissals because the laws impose strict penalties on even minor mistakes.

Dismissals in the Big Apple have shot up from 42% before the reforms to 62% in 2023, Office of Court Administration data show.

The cause led a rally Tuesday with three Big Apple district attorneys — Manhattan’s Alvin Bragg, Brooklyn’s Eric Gonzalez and Queens’ Melinda Katz — standing alongside business leaders with the Partnership for New York City.

Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg, who critics have criticized as being soft-on-crime, wants lawmakers to change discovery laws. Paul Martinka

The lefty Bragg, who has been accused of being soft-on-crime, recounted cases that were dismissed because of a missing Uber receipt and a police officer’s log book not being turned over.

One alleged abuser who violently stripped off his girlfriend’s clothes in front his friends walked free because prosecutors turned over a single piece of evidence late, Bragg recently complained.

Gonzalez pinned the surging dismissals squarely on discovery laws, often because of information that’s not relevant to the cases.

“They have skyrocketed in New York City, in part because there is no forgiveness of any missing paper,” he said.

One alleged abuser who violently stripped off his girlfriend’s clothes in front his friends walked free because prosecutors turned over a single piece of evidence late, Bragg recently complained. New York Post
The city’s case dismissal rate has increased to 62% since discovery reform was passed. Paul Martinka

“What we’re asking for is for proportionality, for a case not to be dismissed because non-relevant information is turned over past that deadline.”

The event unfolded just hours before Republican state lawmakers held a news conference with Nassau County District Attorney Anne Donnelly in Albany expressing their own in support of changing the laws.

Donnelly called Hochul’s proposed changes a “good first step,” as she argued discovery laws make people “less safe.”

Dismissals in the Big Apple have shot up from 42% before the reforms to 62% in 2023, Office of Court Administration data show. Getty Images for National CARES Mentoring Movement

“It’s a disgrace that a case, an important case, would be dismissed” due to a technicality, she told reporters.

But changing the discovery laws also faces fierce opposition from criminal-justice advocates, public defenders and other aligned groups such as the NAACP, who’ve coalesced into the Alliance To Protect Kalief’s Law — named after Kalief Browder, who committed suicide after spending years at Rikers Island awaiting trial for stealing a backpack.

Kalle Condliffe, senior staff attorney at The Legal Aid Society, argued Hochul’s proposals amount to a gutting of Kalief’s Law, meant to keep defendants from languishing in jail while awaiting trial.

The state budget deadline is technically April 1, but lawmakers have blown past it in the past amid discussions on contentious topics such as bail reform. Robert Miller

She said tying the discovery rules — which set strict deadlines that prosecutors disclose evidence within 35 days in most cases — to the state’s speedy trials requirement is “what gives the law meaning.”

Prosecutors will be able to work around the provisions in the governor’s proposal to maliciously influence cases, she argued.

“It’s not about the judges and, to be clear, it’s not a lack of trust,” Condliffe said. “It’s that any party in an adversarial system is going to do the best for their side, according to the rules.”

State Senate Minority Leader Rob Ortt (R-Niagara), however, said the GOP conference won’t accept anything less than what Hochul has proposed.

“It’s like vanilla ice cream,” he said. “I don’t want a watered down vanilla ice cream.”



Source link

Related articles

Jennifer Aniston gate-crash suspect investigated for possible stalking: report

Jennifer Aniston gate-crash suspect investigated for possible stalking: report

May 8, 2025
A “disheveled lunatic” allegedly used a metal rod to smash the head of a pregnant woman on Tuesday afternoon.

New York pregnant woman bashed in the head by ‘disheveled lunatic’ in Chelsea, police say

May 8, 2025
Tags: crimecriminal justice reformsdiscoverydistrict attorneyskathy hochulMetronycUS News
Share76Tweet47
Previous Post

NYPD’s Tisch rails against ‘system’ in honoring Jonathan Diller

Next Post

Florida man found with meth in his underwear tells police ‘there’s nothing wrong with drugs’

Related Posts

Jennifer Aniston gate-crash suspect investigated for possible stalking: report

Jennifer Aniston gate-crash suspect investigated for possible stalking: report

by
May 8, 2025
0

The opposite of “Friends.” The man arrested for allegedly ramming into the gate of Jennifer Aniston’s $21 million home is...

A “disheveled lunatic” allegedly used a metal rod to smash the head of a pregnant woman on Tuesday afternoon.

New York pregnant woman bashed in the head by ‘disheveled lunatic’ in Chelsea, police say

by
May 8, 2025
0

A pregnant woman was smashed in the head with a metal rod by a “disheveled lunatic” in Chelsea on Tuesday,...

Indiana vigilante identified as Mark Vawter wanted revenge on S'Doni Pettis who allegedly killed grandchildren in crash

Indiana vigilante identified as Mark Vawter wanted revenge on S’Doni Pettis who allegedly killed grandchildren in crash

by
May 8, 2025
0

An armed man on a vigilante mission to avenge the killing of his great-grandchildren was gunned down in a chaotic...

Human remains discovered in creepy abandoned New Hampshire shed belong to 'fugitive' sex offender Michael Schilz

Human remains discovered in creepy abandoned New Hampshire shed belong to ‘fugitive’ sex offender Michael Schilz

by
May 8, 2025
0

The skeletal remains discovered in a creepy shed across from a New Hampshire state prison were identified as a wanted...

Police searching for missing Texas girl after mom was arrested for locking starving sister in closet for weeks

Police searching for missing Texas girl after mom was arrested for locking starving sister in closet for weeks

by
May 8, 2025
0

A huge search is underway for a young girl now feared to have vanished in 2017 — with cops only...

Load More
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
The horrifying rape, torture murder of eight-year-old Nurin Jazlin Jazimin : True Crime Diva

The horrifying rape, torture murder of eight-year-old Nurin Jazlin Jazimin : True Crime Diva

May 29, 2023
Drunk driver who killed mother and son blamed the victims, phone calls with father reveal

Drunk driver who killed mother and son blamed the victims, phone calls with father reveal

September 22, 2024
Karen Styles: map of where a deer hunter found her body

The 1994 murder of Karen Styles

May 9, 2023
Mackenzie Shirilla

Father of Mackenzie Shirilla’s boyfriend doesn’t support life sentence

August 20, 2023
The Murder of Latanisha Carmichael – TRUE CRIME REPORT

The Murder of Latanisha Carmichael – TRUE CRIME REPORT

June 7, 2023
The Unsolved Murder of Karina Holmer – TRUE CRIME REPORT

The Unsolved Murder of Karina Holmer – TRUE CRIME REPORT

September 3, 2023
The tragic story of solo traveler Emma Kelty

The tragic story of solo traveler Emma Kelty

May 15, 2023
Karen Styles: map of where a deer hunter found her body

The 1994 murder of Karen Styles

0
Dwane Roy Dreher: photo of his 2nd wife, Lois Genzler Dreher at 16 years old

The 1955 disappearance of U.S. Navy veteran Dwane Roy Dreher

0
Alta Braun: professional photo taken when she was about 4 years old.

The 1917 unsolved murder of Alta Marie Braun

0
Vacation Nightmare: The gruesome murder of Janice Pietropola and Lynn Seethaler

Vacation Nightmare: The gruesome murder of Janice Pietropola and Lynn Seethaler

0
Kristi Nikle: photo of suspect Floyd Tapson

The 1996 disappearance of Kristi Nikle

0
Frank and Tessie Pozar: photo of their son, Frank Pozar, Jr.

Motel Mystery: What happened to Frank and Tessie Pozar?

0
Evil on The Road Part 4: Desmond Joseph Runstedler

Evil on The Road Part 4: Desmond Joseph Runstedler

0
Pt. 1: Fugitive Darren Berg on the Run – Crime Watch Daily with Chris Hansen

Pt. 1: Fugitive Darren Berg on the Run – Crime Watch Daily with Chris Hansen

May 8, 2025
Jennifer Aniston gate-crash suspect investigated for possible stalking: report

Jennifer Aniston gate-crash suspect investigated for possible stalking: report

May 8, 2025
A “disheveled lunatic” allegedly used a metal rod to smash the head of a pregnant woman on Tuesday afternoon.

New York pregnant woman bashed in the head by ‘disheveled lunatic’ in Chelsea, police say

May 8, 2025
Indiana vigilante identified as Mark Vawter wanted revenge on S'Doni Pettis who allegedly killed grandchildren in crash

Indiana vigilante identified as Mark Vawter wanted revenge on S’Doni Pettis who allegedly killed grandchildren in crash

May 8, 2025
Human remains discovered in creepy abandoned New Hampshire shed belong to 'fugitive' sex offender Michael Schilz

Human remains discovered in creepy abandoned New Hampshire shed belong to ‘fugitive’ sex offender Michael Schilz

May 8, 2025
Police searching for missing Texas girl after mom was arrested for locking starving sister in closet for weeks

Police searching for missing Texas girl after mom was arrested for locking starving sister in closet for weeks

May 8, 2025
Animal advocates demand Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg impose stricter penalties on pigeon catchers after poacher's arrest

Animal advocates demand Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg impose stricter penalties on pigeon catchers after poacher’s arrest

May 8, 2025
Beyond the Crime Scene with Bee Astronaut

Categories

  • Featured
  • News
  • Podcast
  • True Crime Stories
  • Videos

Legal Pages

  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA)
  • DMCA

© 2023 All right reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • True Crime Stories
  • Videos
  • Podcast

© 2023 All right reserved.